View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0016721MMW v4Burning / Disc Handlingpublic2020-06-19 01:52
Reporterrusty Assigned To 
Status closedResolutionwon't fix 
Product Version4.1.29 
Target Version4.1.29Fixed in Version4.1.29 
Summary0016721: Selecting 'MusicBrainz' protocol doesn't maintain distinct settings
DescriptionIf user chooses 'MusicBrainz' / 'FreeDB' as the protocol, then like implemented in MM5:
1. User name / domain should be grayed or removed and its settings ignored for the MusicBrainz protocol
2. MusicBrainzServer from ini file should be always loaded on Selecting 'MusicBrainz' protocol (Currently Server field Uses last value of selected protocol on sheet load)

--- Original report ---
If the user chooses 'MusicBrainz' as the protocol, the Server name / User name / domain don't automatically adjust.

This isn't a major issue, but it means that e.g. if a user selects Freedb and chooses a server of, and then switches to Protocl:MusicBrainz, the server settings don't adjust accordingly. This probably won't occur that often so we can just close as 'wontfix' if a fix isn't trivial.

The only reason I raise it is because the above appears to be what happened to the user at QKA-700-55520
--- Original report ---
Steps To Reproduce1. Open FreeDB options
2. Select FreeDB -> For server enter ""
3. Change protocol to MusicBrainz -> Server do not change
4. Edit Server to
5. Change protocol to FreeDB -> Server do not change

NOTE: if in case user press OK after step 3 them MusicBrainzServer in ini file is permanantly changed and CD lookup fail.
Additional InformationQKA-700-55520
TagsNo tags attached.
Fixed in build1909


related to 0016715 closedLudek Freedb lookup no longer works 



2020-06-16 21:42

developer   ~0058567

Last edited: 2020-06-16 21:43

For MM5 it works fine.

For MM4: I don't think that user even need to touch the settings as the default is 'MusicBrainz' protocol with '' and is working, isn't it?
i.e. just verify that the default works fine.


2020-06-16 22:02

developer   ~0058568

Fixed in


2020-06-19 01:52

developer   ~0058598

Verified 1909

MM4 acts like MM5