View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0019851MMW 5Playlists (Auto) / Search / Filterspublic2023-12-15 18:19
Reporterlowlander Assigned To 
PriorityurgentSeverityfeatureReproducibilityalways
Status closedResolutionfixed 
Product Version5.0.4 
Target Version5.1Fixed in Version5.1 
Summary0019851: AutoPlaylist Criteria should show selection tooltip
DescriptionThe problem is if a user selects 15 random items from a selection of a 1000 items (like 15 Albums from a Library of a 1000 items) that there is no easy way to see what is actually selected. Opening the selection itself would require scrolling through a 1000 items to find the 15 selected.
3
1) Add a tooltip on Criteria that shows all selected (multi-line where needed).
2) Always show all items selected (create multi-line where needed). This may become unwieldy though if user selects 900 items.
3) Make all selections a window like Playlist Criteria (which has hide unselected)
TagsNo tags attached.
Fixed in build2828

Relationships

related to 0019852 feedbackrusty Allow manual enter of Criteria values in AutoPlaylists 
related to 0019768 assignedrusty Ability to export/Import Auto-Playlist criteria 

Activities

rusty

2023-10-25 21:32

administrator   ~0073235

I'm not sure I understand. The issue that you describe is that there's no way to easily see all items that the user has selected in a view, but the solution described is specific to AutoPlaylists. If the problem exists in any view, why is the solution specific to AutoPlaylists? Or am I misunderstanding?

lowlander

2023-11-09 17:21

developer   ~0073393

The problem is in the Criteria. So for example you set the Criteria Artist equals and select 10 Artists from a Library of 10,000 Artists. There is no way to easily see what is selected once the selection list extends beyond the window width. Possible solutions:

1. Tooltip showing selection, however this may be unwieldy if user has 100's/1000's of items selected.
2. Multi-line, show full selection starting new lines as needed, still could be unwieldy.
3. Add show only selected, would also allow for easier deselection of selected items.
image.png (25,084 bytes)   
image.png (25,084 bytes)   

rusty

2023-12-13 20:16

administrator   ~0073794

Adding a tooltip (suggestion 1) would solve most cases. Ludek, please push if non-trivial.

Note: another approach that might be anytime multiple items are check-selected (i.e. for auto-playlists, sync lists, multi-attribute fields, etc.) would be to always display the selected items at the top of the list. This allows users to more easily see what items are seleceted and to more easily deselect them. But this would be a future feature (especially since it's not clear that it would be desired behavior for playlist hierarchies).

Ludek

2023-12-14 16:08

developer   ~0073809

The tooltip is added in 5.1.0.2828

lowlander

2023-12-15 18:19

developer   ~0073849

Verified on 2828 that tooltip has been added.