View Issue Details

IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
0015773MediaMonkey 5Playlist / Searchpublic2019-06-20 14:07
Reporterpeke 
PrioritynormalSeverityminorReproducibilityalways
Status feedbackResolutionopen 
Product Version 
Target Version5.1Fixed in Version 
Summary0015773: Auto-Playlists with multiple criteria limits are not supported or imported from MM4
DescriptionAuto Playlists with Multiple Limits fail to import in MM5 as adding multiple limits to Auto-Playlist is not available in MM5

When Playlists have two enable Limits they fail to import and all but one limit is lost.
Steps To ReproduceCreate Auto-Playlist in MM4 with these settings Using ALL Match and Entire Library:
Status -> Is accessible
Type -> Music
Rating >= 5
Track Length <= 660 Seconds (To eliminate long Tracks)
-----------
Sort -> Random -> Z..A
-----------
Limit -> 100 Tracks (At that time my Car Stereo could read up to 100 tracks)
Limit -> 80 Min (If I want to limit that to an Audio CD)
TagsNo tags attached.
Fixed in build

Relationships

related to 0015777 resolvedLudek Auto-Playlists: 'Selected by' doesn't support all fields that users would expect 

Activities

peke

2019-06-18 23:43

developer  

bug15773.jpg (241,546 bytes)
bug15773.jpg (241,546 bytes)

rusty

2019-06-19 06:10

administrator   ~0053875

The solution proposed at 0015777 could also resolve this problem.

peke

2019-06-19 21:03

developer   ~0053900

Note: 0015777 do not solve case with multiple Limitations eg. List up to 100 tracks that are < 650MB

peke

2019-06-20 12:00

developer  

bug15773-2.jpg (595,134 bytes)

Ludek

2019-06-20 12:25

developer   ~0053911

Last edited: 2019-06-20 12:27

View 2 revisions

ok, this seems to be a small usability regression against MM4.
The pros are the clearer, cleaner and compact UI.

I guess that using multiple limitations is rather rare case, probably just the Audio CD example (100 tracks / 80 minutes) ?
Assigned to Rusty to decide whether the UI should be re-designed because of this, but sounds rather as a low priority item to me.

rusty

2019-06-20 14:07

administrator   ~0053912

I agree that this is probably not that common, so,

1) In the short term: Assuming this isn't hard/risky to implement, MM5 should import such playlists from MM4, but with only a single limit (preferentially use limits of minutes, MB, files)
2) In the long term we'll see if this is really a problem. If it is, we can update the UI with a '+' to add a second limit (but not a second option to 'Select by' e.g.
[ ] Limit to _50_ _files__v . . Selected by: _random_ [+]
. . Limit to _100_ _MB_ . . [-]