View Issue Details
| ID | Project | Category | View Status | Date Submitted | Last Update |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0010989 | MMA | Synchronization | public | 2013-06-13 10:10 | 2013-08-09 01:11 |
| Reporter | Ludek | Assigned To | |||
| Priority | urgent | Severity | minor | Reproducibility | have not tried |
| Status | closed | Resolution | fixed | ||
| Product Version | 1.0.4 | ||||
| Target Version | 1.0.4 | Fixed in Version | 1.0.4 | ||
| Summary | 0010989: Implement sync confirmations for bi-di sync | ||||
| Description | We have implemented confirmations for playlists and files in case of USB sync when following is enabled on device profile: [x] Auto-sync files and playlists from the device to the PC .... [x] Confirm Updates Example confirmation of USB sync (build 1642): [x] New file(s) and playlist(s) to copy from the device to the PC (2) --[x] Playlist: PLST2 --[x] \Music\Air\10000 Hz Legend\05 - Radian.mp3 [x] Existing file(s) and playlist(s) to update from the device to the PC (1) --[x] Playlist: PLST1 We should add similar confirmations in case of WiFi sync, more details here 0010689 | ||||
| Tags | No tags attached. | ||||
| Fixed in build | 146 | ||||
| related to | 0009692 | closed | martin | MMA | Improved delete confirmation dialog that allows for deletion of tracks from Playlists |
| related to | 0010990 | closed | martin | MMA | Optimize/Simplify delete confirmation dialog |
| related to | 0010992 | closed | marek | MMA | Empty playlists remain in MMA in cases where they should be deleted |
| related to | 0010993 | closed | marek | MMA | MMA fails to update playlists in response to removal of a track |
| related to | 0011140 | closed | Ludek | MMW v4 | Metadata fail to sync back for read-only files |
| child of | 0010689 | closed | Ludek | MMW v4 | Auto-sync (-->Library) doesn't work as expected for playlists |
|
|
Note that there are also some bugs that needs to be fixed/verified: 0010689:0036471 |
|
|
We currently have the following strings: Confirm deletion Delete the selected item/s from the device? .... .... [Yes] [No] It would probably make sense to have a single sync confirmation dialog so that the user doesn't have to accept multiple dialogs. This could be something like: Confirm updates & deletions [ ] Delete Tracks/Videos (<#>) --[x] <Artist> <Title> --[x] <Artist> <Title> [x] Copy new files and playlists from the device to the PC (<#>) --[x] Playlist: PLST2 --[x] \Music\Air\10000 Hz Legend\05 - Radian.mp3 [x] Update existing files and playlists from the device to the PC (<#>) --[x] Playlist: PLST1 --[x] \Music\Air\10000 Hz Legend\05 - Radian.mp3 [Yes] [No] Note: it might make sense to split files and playlists |
|
|
This general dialog for confirmation of everything is imho not a good idea. There are too many lines and information for small phone display. I know that you want to make it similar to MMW but this layout is to complicated for display. It is most probably unusable even for medium size screens. I think it should be more adjusted and optimized. The main problem is that the display can sometimes display only 6 lines of list (my xperia x10 mini displays even only 3). When you scroll the list and you have like 50 tracks for each category, it is hard to know if you currently check item from second or third category...because the list is simply too long. It is hard to operate even with current, one category, implementation I think that it would be probably better to use on of these approaches: 1. Three simple separate dialogs (I know that you don't want the user to confirm each dialog but it is clear for the user) Confirm delete of tracks[select all button] ------------------------------------------- [ ] <Artist> <Title> [ ] <Artist> <Title> [Yes] [No] .. similarly for other dialogs 2. Use viewpager, i.e. three pages in one dialog, user can switch between these dialogs by swiping. And it will be clearly visible that there are multiple pages Confirm delete [select all button] ----------------------------------- Delete tracks | Copy f --------=============-------------- [ ] <Artist> <Title> [ ] <Artist> <Title> [Yes] [No] The second line represent bar similar to bar in play store application. |
|
|
So if we took the viewpager approach it could appear as: Confirm Updates & Deletions Deletions | Updates | New files Descriptive text for each viewpager screen: Deletions: Items to delete from the device Updates: Items to update on the PC New files & playlists: Items to copy to the PC Note: I assume that there's a single Yes | No for all three items (rather than three separate yes/no prompts). |
|
|
in build 144: - new dialog was implemented - confirmation of media/playlists deletion, media updates implemented - changed synchronization workflow to support common confirmation dialog |
|
|
in build 145: - some style improvements and fixes of dialog What is missing: - confirmation of playlist updates and uploads |
|
|
Implemented in build 146 at MMA side: But confirmation of uploads/updates to MMW is not sent from MMW to MMA in settings XML. I added it as "UpdateConfirm" element. |
|
|
There's always been <BiDirConfirm> element for this, and newly (from build 1644) there is also new element <BiDirSyncMetadata> for file metadata (rating, playcount etc.) |
|
|
Ok, I didn't see it. Fixed in build 146 |
|
|
Verified 146, but I encounter one issues where Read only files are updated which initiate additional Confirmation for updating Tracks and sync can't continue unless it is clicked. My best guess is that those files are updated in Library but not physically. |
|
|
Could you please specify the steps to reproduce it? Update of tracks doesn't have any confirmation...this is implemented only for playlists. Only upload of media to MMW and deletion of track in MMA has to be confirmed (if configured). |
|
|
It is not MMA issue but rather MMW issue. Added steps in 0011140 |
|
|
Verified 1652 and 156 |
