0013072: CD RIP: MMW incorrectly Show error dialogs - MantisBT

ID	Project	Category	View Status	Date Submitted	Last Update

0013072	MMW v4	Burning / Disc Handling	public	2016-01-14 20:30	2017-05-03 10:00

Reporter	peke	Assigned To
Priority	high	Severity	major	Reproducibility	always
Status	closed	Resolution	duplicate
Product Version	4.0.7
Target Version	4.1.11

Summary	0013072: CD RIP: MMW incorrectly Show error dialogs
Description	When Volume leveling is enabled in RIP dialog MMW firstly RIP to WAV in Temp Folder -> Do Volume leveling on Lossless file -> Encodes to Destination. Problem rises when MMW do not have Correct write access to Destination Path. 1. MMW shows Dialog for each file in TEMP folder that MMW can't access it wich incorrect as files are correctly created and accesible eg. They are playable until they are deleted from temp folder by MMW. 2. after user clicks OK for all MMW Shows Dialog with list of tracks not created correctly which is confusing adn implicate that it is bug in MMW, instead it should state that MMW can't create file on destination. NOTE: To confirm access rights I tried to do Auto Organize on one of files from same path and MMW failed to Move them, but also all files are readable and playable. LOG File is on FTP
Additional Information	IPB-846-58952
Tags	No tags attached.
Attached Files	Rip settings.jpg (14,229 bytes) Rip settings.jpg (14,229 bytes)

Fixed in build

peke 2016-01-14 20:31 developer ~0043868	This is long standing issue.

Ludek 2016-01-15 13:23 developer ~0043878	Peke, I cannot reproduce. I tried ripping a file to drive G:\ that is locked SD card (no write access). In both cases (with and without volume leveling enabled) MMW reported error: "File G:\... was not successfuly created" which is expected. Could you specify the exact steps to reproduce the issue?

peke 2016-01-15 15:24 developer ~0043879	There is no special settings or steps only difference is taht user used c:\Temp as temporary folder. Steps are: 1. Insert Audio CD 2. RIP Dialog Shown imediately (but same is if I click on RIP icon on inserted CD) 3. Destination path is set to UNC or Mapped Drive letter 4. Rip Settings are as attached screenshot 5. Temp WAV files are correctly created along with ripping 6. Volume leveling is done on files 7. Before convert MMW throw error for each WAV (till number of audio tracks from CD) that it can't access it 8. After pressing OK for all tracks it shows "File ?????? was not successfully created" (as expected doe the no write access) Dialogs in 7. are not needed and do not know why they show at all LOG files should show why especially as I tried to RIP same CD into c:\TEMP folder and it ripped without problems.

Ludek 2016-01-18 14:24 developer ~0043884 Last edited: 2016-01-18 14:24	OK, so my understanding is that you also cannot reproduce it and at step 7 there is no error dialog for you, right? From the user's log I saw this: "Geen toegang tot C:\Temp\212F.wav. Toegang is geweigerd. Het bestand is in gebruik of er zijn onvoldoende rechten." Which means that file C:\Temp\212F.wav is in use or there isn't enough rights to write. It really seems that another app or something locked the files in the C:\Temp\ for the user for some reason. So probably the error was right, just the reason is unknown (why the files were read only ATM)

peke 2016-01-18 15:08 developer ~0043886	I do not think so as after step 8 all wav files are deleted correctly. Another strange thing is that it only happen if destination path is read only.