0015654: 4x1 widget shows as 5x2 widget on certain devices - MantisBT

ID	Project	Category	View Status	Date Submitted	Last Update

0015654	MMA	General	public	2019-05-07 21:19	2022-12-14 18:14

Reporter	lowlander	Assigned To
Priority	normal	Severity	minor	Reproducibility	sometimes
Status	resolved	Resolution	reopened
Product Version	1.3.5
Target Version	1.3.5

Summary	0015654: 4x1 widget shows as 5x2 widget on certain devices
Description	The 4x1 compact widget shows as a 5x2 widget on certain devices. Huawei p10+ and Asus Zenfone 5Q are affected.
Additional Information	FOL-325-22068 Note: the images below compare: 1) the widgets available for Google Music vs MM (you can see that Google Music has a 4x1 widget that doesn't get modified, whereas the MM 4x1 widget is dynamically modified to 5x2) 2) how the Google Music and MMA widgets display
Tags	No tags attached.
Attached Files	1557263046864.JPEG (32,112 bytes) 1557263046864.JPEG (32,112 bytes) 1557263090415.JPEG (40,043 bytes) 1557263090415.JPEG (40,043 bytes) 1557263395627.JPEG (34,241 bytes) 1557263395627.JPEG (34,241 bytes) 1557263641783.JPEG (36,569 bytes) 1557263641783.JPEG (36,569 bytes) Screenshot_4x4.jpg (162,337 bytes) Screenshot_4x4.jpg (162,337 bytes) Screenshot_5x5.jpg (127,714 bytes) Screenshot_5x5.jpg (127,714 bytes) Screenshot_Placeholder.jpg (174,153 bytes) Screenshot_Placeholder.jpg (174,153 bytes)

Fixed in build	857

rusty 2019-05-07 21:24 administrator ~0053444	I think that the fact that the MM widgets are dynamically resizable in _width_ is a good thing, but only if they don't also resize in height. If there's no simple solution to this issue, perhaps the easiest approach would be to add a 5x1 widget.

martin 2019-05-09 10:11 developer ~0053446	Fixed in build 1.3.5.857

peke 2019-06-05 22:34 developer ~0053742	Verified 857 All widgets show correct size and occupy correct size on screen.

lowlander 2019-06-11 17:04 developer ~0053796	On 858 Tiny 2x1 occupies 2x2 Compact 4x1 occupies 5x2 Full 4x2 occupies 5x2 Large 4x4 occupies 5x5 Only Media 2x2 occupies 2x2

peke 2019-06-11 19:26 developer ~0053798	Can you explain how you determined that MMA widgets occupie more space? For me I added 5x5 Icons on Screen and removed enough to Fit one MMA widget at time. In pre 857 I could not Put Widget in That space and in 857 Widgets fits without issues. After that i Removed all widgets and Added one by one to compare screenshots if they are same and widget is correctly occupy assigned space?

martin 2019-11-11 11:10 developer ~0055294	Each widget has minWidth and minHeight which depends on elements in the layout. The size classification 4x4 or 5x5 is affected by launcher. So same widget on one phone can be represented as 4x4 and on other as 5x5 1) Tiny 2x1 no resizable 2) Medium 2x2 resizeMode="horizontal\|vertical" 3) Compat 5x1 resizeMode="horizontal" 4) Full 4x2(5x2) resizeMode="horizontal" 5) Full 4x4(5x5) resizeMode="horizontal\|vertical" Each widget is resizeable only in dimension witch makes sense (according to elements in layout).